To distinguish partnerships from simple transactional relationships, we define partnerships as having the following characteristics. A partnership:1

  • requires seed funding from one or more partners, or an external source, and/or dedicated staff time;

  • provides mutual benefits to all partners;

  • requires shared risks and responsibilities for all partners, and

  • results in measurable outcomes.

Partnership evaluation questions1

  1. Provide a brief, high-level description of the partnership (context for the questions that follow).

  2. General questions

    1. Why do we wish to engage with this particular partner (or why is this a good potential partner)?  

    2. What type of organization is the partner organization (e.g. nonprofit, for-profit)? Is it mission-driven?

    3. Describe the organization’s history, track record, and standing in its community.

    4. How does the partnership advance arXiv’s priorities?

    5. What are the potential opportunity costs?

    6. Why do they want to engage with us?

    7. Do the partners share a vision, and if they do, what is it?

    8. What evidence is there of commitment to the success of this partnership?

    9. What are the potential benefits to arXiv and to the partner?

    10. What are the potential risks to arXiv and to the partner?

    11. What are the partners’ tolerance for risk?

    12. Is there a reasonable exit strategy (explain)?

    13. Note any other considerations/concerns.

  3. Governance, decision-making

    1. How will governance be handled?

    2. How will priorities be set?

    3. How will decisions be made?

    4. How will IP be managed between the partners?

    5. What considerations or requirements might constrain or impact our ability to collaborate on grant proposals? What will the roles of the partners be?

    6. Note any other considerations/concerns.

  4. Resources

    1. What arXiv and partner resources are required to start and sustain the partnership?

    2. What are the partners willing to contribute?

    3. What costs will be incurred and how will they be distributed between the partners?

    4. Note any other considerations/concerns.

  5. Software development process

    1. How will the work get done? Co-development, parallel, etc.

    2. What development practices will be employed?

    3. Note any other considerations/concerns.



1  Adapted from Koltay et al. 2016. Partnerships: Assessing when to start, when to hold, and when to fold. College & Research Libraries News 77(2). Online:

  • No labels