...
In order to determine the critical velocity at which floc particles will begin to roll up the tube and into the effluent, we compare the settling velocity with the particle velocity experienced from the velocity gradient.
The settling velocity can of a particle in a tube settler can be expressed as follows:
Where:
g = Gravity
d0= size of the primary particles
Dfractal= fractal dimension of the floc particles
phi = shape factor for drag on flocs which is equal to/
v = viscosity
rho floc = density of the floc particle
rho h2o = density of water
The particle velocity expereinced The particle velocity expereince as a result of the velocity gradient can be expressed as follows:
insert vparticle here
Where
Valpha = directional velocity in the tube settler
dtube = diameter of the tube settler
dfloc = the diameter of floc particleswhere phi is the shape factor, equivalent to 45/24
Therefore, the ratio between the settling velocity of the particle and the velocity experienced as a result of the velocity gradient can be expressed as
insert velocity ratio formula here
This ratio is a function of particle diameter. When this ratio is greater than one (ie the settling velocity is greater than the velocity experienced by the floc particles in the tube), the flocs will fall back into floc blanket and fail to travel to the effluent. When this ratio is equal to one, the particles will remain stationary in the tube settler. And when the ratio is less than one, the velocity of the particles will exceed the settling velocity and the floc particles will roll up into the effluent, creating a highter turbidity.
Figure 1: The ratio of Sedimentation Velocity to Fluid Velocity vs. Floc Diameter
Figure 1 shows what size floc could be captured by different tube settler diameters. The lines cross the y value of 1 when the sedimentation velocity matches the upflow velocity at the floc diameter, and this is the critical velocity, i.e. the velocity in which floc roll up will begin, for each of the given tube diameters and plate settler spacing.
Calculation of the Minimum Diameter of the Flocs that Settle from the Sedimentation Velocity Equation
Assuming an upward flow velocity of 100 m/day, which is standard in all AguaClara plants, the diameter of floc that will roll-up was determined by using a root finding algorithm, and the plate settling or settler spacing or tube diameter was plotted versus the minimum floc diameter.
Figure 2: Plate Spacing or Tube Diameter vs. Minimum Floc Diameter
The minimum floc diameter corresponds to the minimum size of particles that will still settle out of the tube and return to the floc blanket instead of going into the effluent. This graph is based on the capture velocity theory, and must be revised to take into consideration floc roll-up that will occur in the plate settlers.
To ensure that flocs in the plate settler don't roll up, we can calculate the minimum floc diameter that settle settles from the sedimentation velocity equation. Solving for the floc diameter,
insert floc diameter eqtns
insert S equations and explanations?
This equation is based on a linearization of the velocity profile at the wall. It uses the velocity gradient at the wall to determine the velocity as a function of distance from the wall. For small floc sizes this linearization is valid and produces an analytical solutio 
Figure 3: Floc Diameter vs. Spacing
Figure 3 shows how the linearized equations provide only tiny divergence for big flocs in small tubes.
Figure 4: Floc Spacing vs. Floc Diameter
Figure 4 graphically displays the linear velocity gradient solutions. The curves are not quite straight on a log log plot. This is due to the quadratic in the velocity profile. We can obtain a very good approximation by using the velocity gradient at the wall and assuming a linear velocity gradient. That assumption makes an analytical solution possible.
...
Figure 5: Minimum spacing vs. Floc Sedimentation
Figure 6: Minimum Plate Settler Spacing vs. Capture Velocity
The Reynold's Number was checked to ensure that the flow in the settler tube is in fact laminar. Next, the entrance region was checked to ensure that the parabolic velocity profile was fully established.
Figure 7: Ratio of Entrance Length to Plate Length vs. Plate Spacing
Figure 7 shows that the entrance regions are always less than the length of the plate setltlers. Thus, based on this analysis, the best designs would include plates that are more closely spaced. All of the plate settlers will have a significant entrance region. It is likely that the only way flocs can successfully pass thorugh the entrance region is to grow into larger flocs so they have a higher sedimentation velocity.
...